← LearningPortrait

Beatriz Villarroel

at work today · A portrait

An astronomer at Nordita leads VASCO, a project comparing century-old sky photographs to modern surveys, and has reported point-like objects present in one exposure and gone in the next, unexplained so far.

How to read it

The line above is how her claims were received — by the scientists whose job was to doubt them. It rises as a claim is tested and accepted, and the room brightens with it. It is not a verdict on truth: some accepted ideas are later overturned, and some rejected ones come back. A hollow point is a claim still open.

drag along the line to travel
1 of 5 · 2019 · proposed

The first vanishing stars

She led the VASCO project's first paper, published in The Astronomical Journal, comparing a 1950s sky catalogue to modern surveys and reporting about 100 previously catalogued stars no longer visible, including one followed up directly with telescope time.

2 of 5 · 2021 · proposed

Multiple transients

A peer-reviewed paper in Scientific Reports described dozens of aligned "multiple transients," several point-like flashes appearing together in one exposure, unexplained by any known object or process at the time of the plates.

3 of 5 · 2024 · contested

The artifact critique

Astronomers Hambly and Blair, in RAS Techniques and Instruments, argued the reported transients are more likely flaws in the photographic emulsion, pointing to profiles narrower than ordinary stars. Villarroel's team disputed the comparison as circular.

4 of 5 · 2025 · proposed

A technosignature framing

Villarroel's team published companion papers proposing some transients could be glints from objects near Earth, reporting a statistical link between transient counts and nuclear weapons tests and reports of unidentified phenomena.

5 of 5 · 2026 · proposed

A statistical rebuttal

Astronomer Wesley Watters and colleagues, in Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia, published a peer-reviewed critique arguing the statistical case for a nuclear-test link doesn't hold up. Villarroel's team answered in a 2026 preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.

The transients are still a genuine puzzle. What they are is still argued over.
What her project leaves open is whether every point of light that appears once on old film is a flaw in the plate, or something the sky actually did.
scroll to walk
1 / 8